Quick Picks
Single-entry captain: C.J. Stroud ($15,000), the likeliest top scorer tonight by my count, Build 1.
Large-field captain: Tyler Warren ($12,600), the Colts tight end who draws the most targets on his team, Build 4.
Contrarian captain: HOU DST ($8,700), a Texans pass rush facing a Colts line without either starting tackle, Build 5.
Cheap piece: Laquon Treadwell ($4,000), a perfect three-for-three night last week for 24 yards and a touchdown.
The Game
Indianapolis plays tonight without both of its starting tackles, Bernhard Raimann and Jalen Travis, and Will Anderson brings 10.5 sacks in eight games to the other side of the ball. Houston is a double-digit favorite with a total near 44, which puts the Texans around 27 points and the Colts around 17. The Texans' stadium in Houston will have its roof closed, so the weather won't matter.
I expect about 123 snaps between the two teams, roughly one more than an average game, per our NFL pace of play board. Indianapolis plays a bit quicker in neutral script with the 17th fastest pace, while Houston ranks 21st, so neither side will push the tempo much.
The ceiling version of this game has Stroud spreading it to Nico Collins and Xavier Hutchinson early, then Daniel Jones throwing to Tyler Warren to stay close. The floor version has Houston up two scores by halftime, Anderson living in the Colts backfield, and Indianapolis handing the ball to Jonathan Taylor to shorten the night.
Game Overview
Switch tabs for the injuries that move this game and our top plays.
| Player | Status | Impact (1-10) | Who benefits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Woody Marks, HOU RB | Out | 7 | David Montgomery, a 14.5-carry line at three books in his first game since Week 5 |
| Will Mallory, IND TE | Out | 7 | Anthony Gould, target share up to 7.3% from 4.2% |
| Marvin Harrison Jr., HOU WR | Out | 5 | Nico Collins, target share up to 23.4% from 22.2% |
| Player | Category | Salary | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| C.J. Stroud | Overall | $10,000 | Threw eight touchdown passes over his last two games and holds a 259.5-yard passing line. |
| Nico Collins | Overall | $10,200 | Drew 16 targets last week and turned them into nine catches, 94 yards and a score. |
| Tyler Warren | Overall | $8,400 | Gets about a quarter of the Colts targets and stays on the field in their two-tight-end sets. |
| Xavier Hutchinson | Value | $6,200 | Scored in each of his last three games and saw nine targets last week. |
| Laquon Treadwell | Value | $4,000 | Caught every ball thrown his way last week, one of them for a touchdown. |
| Ka'imi Fairbairn | Leverage | $5,400 | Lands in the best lineup far more often than the crowd will play him. |
| HOU DST | Leverage | $8,700 CPT | Faces a Colts line with backups at both tackle spots. |
| Kayshon Boutte | Dart Throw | $5,000 | Put up 125 yards and two touchdowns in Week 9. |
| Seth McGowan | Dart Throw | $4,600 | Ran 12 times for 77 yards and a touchdown last week. |
Full ranked board, updated all week: NFL injury report for DFS
Pass Rush Matchup
Houston's front ranks sixth in our DL ranks, and it faces a Colts line ranked 21st with Raimann and Travis both out. Anderson leads the Texans with 23 pressures and 10.5 sacks, Logan Hall adds 10 pressures and four sacks, and Danielle Hunter is out with a hamstring injury. Houston pressures the quarterback on 25.8% of dropbacks and brings him down on 9.5% of them, and the Colts offense has fed opposing defenses 9.00 DK points a night across 10 games, second highest. The HOU DST ($5,800) works as a FLEX piece and as a live captain, and Jones's floor drops with it. The NFL OL vs DL matchups board covers both sides.
Houston's line wins the other side of this matchup. The Colts front ranks 20th against a Houston line ranked third, with no Texans starter hurt, and DeForest Buckner is now in San Francisco. Laiatu Latu leads Indianapolis with 17 pressures, three of them sacks, and Stroud has gone down on just 5.0% of his dropbacks behind this line, which leaves the IND DST ($3,400) with little to work with.
Run Game Matchup
Neither run game carries a clear edge. Indianapolis's run blocking ranks 11th against a Houston run defense ranked 13th, with Colts backs at 4.48 yards per rush and the Texans allowing 4.09. Houston's run blocking ranks 27th against a Colts run defense also ranked 27th, where Texans backs average 3.39 per rush and Indianapolis allows 4.63.
Indianapolis Colts

Laquon Treadwell ($4,000) went three-for-three last week for 24 yards and a touchdown, after one 18-yard grab in Week 8. I'd guess three or four looks tonight, and the books post him at 2.5 grabs and 24.5 yards. Over nine games, Houston's pass defense has handed wide receivers 37.18 DK points a night, fourth most. He's my cheap piece, and he's in the second and fifth builds.
Anthony Gould ($3,000) is questionable with a toe injury after two catches on four targets for 28 yards last week, and with Will Mallory out his target share climbs a little. Ashton Dulin ($3,600) caught a 55-yard touchdown in Week 9 and one pass for 30 yards last week, and Deion Burks ($2,800) hasn't caught a pass in two games. None of the three makes my builds.
Tyler Warren ($8,400) was targeted 10 times in Week 8 and seven times in Week 9 before last week's three-target, one-yard dud. I expect about eight targets, a 26.2% target share, with lines of 5.5 catches and 36.5 yards. Indianapolis used at least two tight ends on 43.6% of its 2025 plays, which keeps Warren on the field. Tight ends have managed only 11.07 DK points a night against Houston over those nine games, eighth fewest, which is why I like him more as a contrarian captain than a cash anchor. Build 4 makes him the captain, and Builds 3 and 5 use him in the FLEX.
Jonathan Taylor ($10,600) ran 16 times for 83 yards and caught two of four targets for 20 yards last week, and he scored on an 18-carry, 95-yard day in Week 7. His lines are 13.5 carries, 51.5 yards and 3.5 catches, and I have him near 13 carries with about five targets. In 2025 the Colts gained 7.30 yards a carry on 37 runs off left tackle, but Raimann played that spot, so I'm not counting on that lane tonight. Taylor goes in the FLEX of the last three builds and never at captain. Seth McGowan ($4,600) took 12 carries for 77 yards and a touchdown last week, but he has two targets in four games, which leaves him as a dart that needs a touchdown.
Daniel Jones completed 11 of 22 passes for 108 yards with a touchdown and two interceptions last week, after going 20 of 34 for 180 yards in Week 9. The books set his lines at 180.5 passing yards and 32.5 attempts, plus 3.5 runs, and I expect about 31 throws. Two backup tackles against Anderson is a hard night for any quarterback, but his legs give him a floor at $8,800, keeping him in play at FLEX in three builds (1, 4 and 5) and as a cash-game FLEX.
Houston Texans

Nico Collins ($10,200) caught nine of 16 targets for 94 yards and a touchdown last week. With Marvin Harrison Jr. out, I expect about eight targets and a 23.4% target share; his lines are 4.5 catches and 70.5 yards. Our ratings see no bigger mismatch tonight than Houston's receivers against the Colts secondary. Most of his outcomes bunch near the middle, but the right side runs long, so Build 2 has him at captain and Build 1 slots him at FLEX. He'll be one of the most popular pieces on the slate. Hutchinson gives up a few points to him on a normal night, but on the nights Hutchinson outscores him, a lineup without Collins jumps past a big chunk of the field.
Xavier Hutchinson ($6,200) has scored in each of his last three games, and last week he caught four of nine targets for 58 yards. Over the last two weeks he was targeted 195 air yards down the field and caught 87 of them. I have him for five or six targets, and the books sit at 3.5 catches and 35.5 yards. Hutchinson is the captain of Build 3, with FLEX spots in the second and fifth builds.
Tank Dell ($6,400) caught four passes for 105 yards and a touchdown in Week 9, then three for 21 yards last week, and his lines are 2.5 catches and 36.5 yards. Kayshon Boutte ($5,000) had a 125-yard, two-touchdown game in Week 9 but failed to catch his only target last week. In 2025, Kayshon Boutte averaged 13.09 yards per target versus zone on 33 targets and 9.15 versus man on 13, and Indianapolis played zone on 63.5% of its snaps last season, so he's my favorite dart throw of the two. Neither is in the builds.
Dalton Schultz ($4,800) turned two targets into an 11-yard touchdown last week, after five catches for 45 yards in Week 7. I expect about five targets, and his lines are 3.5 catches and 29.5 yards. He's the cheap way to stack Stroud, and Builds 1 and 4 both use him.
David Montgomery ($8,200) hasn't played since Week 5, but he's no longer on the injury report and Woody Marks is out. The books trust him with the work, posting 14.5 carries and 56.5 rushing yards, so I'm leaning on those lines rather than his recent role. If he takes the lead job, Emari Demercado ($7,400) is a change-of-pace back who carried six and seven times over the past two weeks. If Montgomery is eased in, Demercado's 20.5-yard rushing line looks light. Montgomery is in Build 2 only and never at captain, and Demercado is in Build 4.
C.J. Stroud completed 20 of 38 passes for 211 yards and three touchdowns last week, after a 384-yard, five-touchdown day in Week 9. His lines are 259.5 passing yards and 32.5 attempts, and I have him around 34 throws behind a line ranked third. At $10,000 he's my cash-game quarterback, the Build 1 captain, and he fills a FLEX role in Builds 2 and 3.
Kickers and Defenses
Both books that price Ka'imi Fairbairn ($5,400) set him at 8.5 kicking points, against 5.5 for Spencer Shrader ($5,200) at the same two books. A double-digit favorite indoors gives Fairbairn the busier night, and the first three builds use him, while Shrader isn't in any.
Build 5 uses the HOU DST ($5,800) at captain, and the first, third and fourth builds use it in the FLEX, because that pass rush gets two backup tackles all night. The IND DST ($3,400) isn't in the builds. By my count the Texans defense posts the game's best score about one night in 22, Fairbairn about one in 36 and the Colts defense about one in 170. Roughly 10% of past winners used a kicker or defense at captain, and the Texans defense is my pick to join them tonight.
The Captain's Chair
C.J. Stroud at $15,000 is my single-entry captain. Stroud wins the captain spot about one time in four by my count, while 17.9% of entries will put him there, and no one on the board shows a wider gap in his favor. When he's the right captain, Dalton Schultz lands in the best lineup more than four times in ten, well above his usual rate, and Hutchinson rides along a third of the time. The Colts defense is the poor fit next to him.
Tyler Warren at $12,600 is my large-field captain. He tops my captain list about one time in 15, a touch more often than the 5.8% of entries expected to start him there, and when he gets there Daniel Jones is in the best lineup about two times in three. Build 4 pairs them. The contrarian call is the HOU DST at $8,700, which wins the captain spot roughly once every 22 games against a crowd rate of 2.4%, and Stroud and Collins are its natural partners. Seth McGowan is the poor fit there. I'm underweight on Jonathan Taylor at captain, where 14.5% of entries will put him even though he finishes first a little less often than that.
| Player | CPT Salary | Best CPT % | CPT Own % | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C.J. Stroud | $15,000 | 25.0% | 17.9% | +7.0 |
| Nico Collins | $15,300 | 14.0% | 13.1% | +0.9 |
| Jonathan Taylor | $15,900 | 13.0% | 14.5% | -1.6 |
| Tyler Warren | $12,600 | 6.7% | 5.8% | +0.9 |
| Xavier Hutchinson | $9,300 | 5.2% | 4.6% | +0.6 |
| Daniel Jones | $13,200 | 4.9% | 2.7% | +2.2 |
Best CPT % is how often a player finishes as the top scorer in the game in our numbers; CPT Own % is how often we expect the field to start him at captain.
Past winners in lopsided games still took pieces from both teams. Roughly half of past winners played both quarterbacks, and Build 1 is the one here that does. Kickers or defenses showed up on 61% of winners, and every one of these five builds carries at least one. The typical winner summed about 235% ownership, and the Warren and Texans-defense builds come in well under that, which is the price of those captains.
Stack Ideas
| Build | CPT | FLEX | Salary | Game Script |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | C.J. Stroud | Nico Collins, Daniel Jones, HOU DST, Ka'imi Fairbairn, Dalton Schultz | $50,000 | Stroud throws for three scores, Collins and Schultz catch them, and the Texans defense feasts on a patched Colts line. |
| 2 | Nico Collins | C.J. Stroud, David Montgomery, Xavier Hutchinson, Ka'imi Fairbairn, Laquon Treadwell | $49,100 | Collins wins early, Montgomery closes it out on the ground, and Fairbairn adds the field goals. |
| 3 | Xavier Hutchinson | Jonathan Taylor, C.J. Stroud, Tyler Warren, HOU DST, Ka'imi Fairbairn | $49,500 | Hutchinson keeps finding the end zone while Taylor and Warren carry the Colts side. |
| 4 | Tyler Warren | Jonathan Taylor, Daniel Jones, Emari Demercado, HOU DST, Dalton Schultz | $50,000 | The Colts hang within a score, so Jones keeps feeding Warren underneath, which is why this one splits three and three. |
| 5 | HOU DST | Jonathan Taylor, Daniel Jones, Tyler Warren, Xavier Hutchinson, Laquon Treadwell | $46,700 | Houston's rush takes over with sacks and turnovers while Jones throws from behind to Warren and Treadwell. |
Lineup Rules
If Stroud captains: add Nico Collins or Xavier Hutchinson plus Dalton Schultz, and one to three Colts.
If Collins or Hutchinson captains: Stroud goes in the FLEX.
If Warren captains: Daniel Jones goes in the FLEX.
If a lineup has two pass catchers from one team: add the quarterback throwing to them.
In every lineup: include a Colt and a Texan.
The five builds follow all five rules, and the site's free NFL lineup optimizer will enforce them across a full set of entries.
Model Recommended Bets
In our game simulations Houston wins 26-17, a margin a few points shy of the spread, with a total of 43.5, dead on the market. No recorded bet clears our bar for this game, and the full week's card is on our NFL game simulator page.
Not financial advice. These are model leans, not guarantees. Only bet what you can afford to lose. 21+. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Long Shot Touchdown Bets
Only one price on the board clears my bar, Daniel Jones at +800. Jones carries three to five times most weeks, and our number gives him a 12.9% shot at the end zone against 9.8% from the books. A +800 ticket needs to hit more than once every nine tries, and our number clears that, so I'd keep the stake small.
Our numbers run cooler than the market on Nico Collins (+101), 41.7% to score against our 37.7%, and on Kayshon Boutte (+330), 20.6% against our 17.6%. I'd pass on both.
Not financial advice. These are model leans, not guarantees. Only bet what you can afford to lose. 21+. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Final Thoughts
My one-entry lineup is Build 1: Stroud at CPT with Nico Collins, Daniel Jones, the HOU DST, Ka'imi Fairbairn and Dalton Schultz.
Before lock I'm watching Anthony Gould's toe and how the Texans split the backfield. If Montgomery looks limited early, Demercado's role grows, and Build 4 already carries him.
For a big tournament, Warren or the Texans defense at captain, with Taylor in the FLEX, steers clear of the crowded Stroud, Collins and Taylor captain spots.
FAQ
Who is the best captain for Colts vs. Texans tonight?
C.J. Stroud at $15,000 for a single entry. In bigger contests, Tyler Warren at $12,600 wins the captain spot a shade above the share of entries that will put him there.
Should I play a kicker or defense in the Colts vs. Texans showdown?
The HOU DST gets the nod against a Colts line missing both starting tackles, and Ka'imi Fairbairn handles the kicking side with 8.5-point lines at both books. Every build carries a kicker or defense.
Who is the best cheap play for Colts vs. Texans?
Laquon Treadwell at $4,000, who scored on a three-for-three night last week.
Is David Montgomery playing for the Texans tonight?
No injury tag is attached to David Montgomery, and the books post a 14.5-carry line for Montgomery, but he hasn't played since Week 5, so he's in only one build and never at captain.
Tools used for this slate
The five builds started from this week's NFL DFS projections and the free NFL lineup optimizer, which prices every showdown captain.
NFL defense against the position showed how much Houston gives up to wide receivers and how little to tight ends, NFL run gap efficiency found the left tackle lane the Colts lose with Bernhard Raimann out, NFL coverage splits by receiver put Kayshon Boutte against a zone-heavy Colts defense, NFL personnel groupings showed how often Indianapolis plays two tight ends, and NFL Elo ratings marked Houston's receivers against the Colts secondary as the widest gap in the game.
NFL weather and roof status confirmed a closed roof in Houston, live NFL odds and totals carries the spread and the touchdown prices, and the NFL DFS hub ties it all together.
